Grade your Google listing the way an auditor would.
Eight areas. One letter each. About an hour, no paid tools.
You grade a Google Business Profile across eight areas: ownership, name and address and phone, primary category, services, photos, reviews, hours and activity, and whether the website agrees with the listing. Each gets a letter, A to F, from what is publicly visible. It takes about an hour, and the lowest letter is almost always the thing to fix first.
Before you start
Everything a grader looks at is public. So you can grade yourself tonight, and you can grade the three practices above you in the map, which is more useful. The gap between your card and theirs is your to-do list.
This is the rubric behind the profile report in our free audit. Nothing is held back. Plenty of owners read it, do it themselves and never call, which is a good outcome.
Have three things open: your Google Business Profile, signed in as yourself; your website in a second tab; and your main patient search in Google Maps on your phone.
Three notes that save an hour of confusion
- Search from your phone, on cellular, in a private window. Office Wi-Fi tells Google you are standing at your own address, which flatters your position.
- Grade your competitors first. Search the way a patient would ("pediatrician near me," "direct primary care [city]") and grade the three practices in the map box before yourself. Otherwise you anchor on what you have rather than on what winning looks like.
- Write the letters down. "Photos need work" is a feeling; a C is a measurement you can compare next month.
The eight areas, and how to grade each one
The thresholds are ours, not Google's. An A means nothing to fix here; an F means this is costing you patients today. Where Google has published a rule, the source is linked.
Area 1. Who owns the listing
A: verified, and your own account is the primary owner. C: you are only a manager. F: unclaimed, suspended, or a duplicate listing shows above the real one.
Look at who has access. If a former office manager, the web designer, a hospital system you used to belong to or a marketing company from years ago is the primary owner, you are one resignation away from losing the most valuable free listing your practice has. Ask for the transfer today.
Then search your practice name, and each provider's name, in Google Maps. Google allows one listing for the practice and one per public-facing practitioner (source: Google); anything beyond that is a duplicate that splits your reviews. Naming and merging them is covered on Google Business Profile for doctors. Never delete a listing with reviews on it.
Area 2. Name, address and phone
A: the listing name matches the name on your door exactly, one phone number appears everywhere, and the address matches your website footer character for character. C: a different phone number on the listing than on the site, or "Suite 200" on one and "Ste 210" on the other. F: anything in the business name that is not the name.
“Example Family Direct Care | Best DPC Doctor Anytown” is the kind of name competitors report. Google's rules say unnecessary information in the name is not permitted and can lead to suspension (source: Google). It works until it doesn't, and then it can take the listing with it.
Compare the listing to your website, then to your NPPES record, the national provider registry that doctor directories copy from; a wrong phone number there reappears on sites you have never heard of, so fix it upstream first. And use one real office number everywhere: a call-tracking number on the listing is a second phone number for your practice, and directories will copy it too. What NAP consistency means, and why the NPPES record comes first.
Area 3. Primary category
A: the narrowest category that is accurate for the clinician's license and the practice's core work, matching what the practices above you use. C: accurate but broad ("Medical clinic," "Doctor"). F: it describes something you are not, or no practice in the map box uses it.
Google says the categories you choose affect your local ranking, and its advice is to pick as few as accurately describe your core business (source: Google). Whitespark's annual survey of local SEO practitioners ranks the primary category the most influential field on the profile (source). A pediatric practice under “Medical clinic” is not losing the pediatrician searches on quality. It has told Google it belongs somewhere vaguer.
To check it, read the gray line under each competitor's name in the map box. That is their primary category. If all three say one thing and you say another, you have found your first fix, and it takes a minute.
The categories a practice usually chooses between are Medical clinic, Family practice physician, Pediatrician and Naturopathic practitioner. Functional medicine is not a Google category, and as of September 2026 we find none for direct primary care either, so the choice is a judgment call: use the narrowest one that is accurate for the license and put “functional medicine” or “direct primary care” in your services and description, which is Area 4. Add other categories only for things you genuinely do.
Area 4. Services and the description
A: every service you want more of is listed with a one- or two-sentence description in patients' words, and the business description opens with what you are, where, and how you are paid. C: services listed but bare, or a description that begins "Welcome to." F: the services field is empty or holds Google's auto-suggestions unedited.
This is the field we find empty most often, and one of the fastest to fill. It matters more for a cash-pay practice, because no category says “membership” or “no insurance.” Services and the description are the only places on the listing where “direct primary care,” “first visit for new patients” or “telehealth for patients in [states]” can live.
List services in the order you want the work, in a patient's words, not a billing code's. Then check that each one has a page on your website; that is Area 8, and the two are graded together.
Area 5. Photos
A: twenty or more real photos, something added in the last ninety days, covering the exterior, the entrance, the waiting area, an exam room and the team. C: ten to twenty, nothing recent. F: fewer than ten, or visibly stock.
Recency matters as much as count. Sixty photos uploaded one afternoon three years ago reads as abandoned, to Google and to the person deciding whether you still exist.
Phone photos of the real place beat stock, because the job is to look real and findable: the building a new patient has to locate, the door, the front desk, the exam room, the clinicians. Two rules for a practice. Never a patient, even from behind; ask your compliance adviser before posting anyone who doesn't work for you. And no stock clinicians. One sales pitch to settle: we know of no evidence that adding location data to photo files changes where a listing appears. Don't pay for it.
Area 6. Reviews: count, rating, recency, replies
A: your total is within reach of the three practices above you, new reviews arrive steadily, and every review has a reply that never confirms the writer was a patient. C: a healthy total but nothing new in six months, or replies to the good ones only. F: fewer than ten reviews, unanswered one-star reviews at the top, or any reply that mentions a visit.
Compare your count to your map box, not to an absolute target. Fifty reviews is strong where the leaders have sixty and thin where they have four hundred. Recency is what most owners miss.
Reply to all of them. Thank the writer, state your general policy, invite them to call the office. Never confirm the reviewer was seen, and never mention anything about care; the reviewer going public first doesn't change that. A practice settled with the HHS Office for Civil Rights in 2023 over a reply that disclosed patient information (source: HHS); reply templates are on Google Business Profile for doctors. We are not lawyers; ask yours.
This is the one area you cannot fix alone in an afternoon. It needs a small system, inside two rules. Google's policy prohibits incentives of any kind, and the FTC's 2024 rule prohibits incentives conditioned on the review being positive (source: Google, source: FTC). Google also prohibits asking only your happy patients, and the FTC rule bans fake reviews. The wording, the timing and the link are in how to ask patients for reviews without breaking the rules.
Area 7. Hours and activity
A: hours are correct, including holidays, they match your website, and something on the listing has changed in the last ninety days. C: hours right, nothing changed in a year. F: hours wrong, or "open" on the listing means voicemail at the desk.
If the listing says open until five and nobody answers at 4:50, that is an F whatever else is true. Why the phone at 4:50 matters more than it seems.
Be careful with posts in both directions. We have not seen evidence that posting moves a listing's position much, so don't pay a lot for weekly posts. But a listing with no sign of life in a year reads as closed. One or two posts a month about something true, such as new hours or a new provider, is enough. Don't grade the public questions-and-answers section: Google has retired it (the note on Google Business Profile for doctors has the detail), and its work now falls to your services, description and site.
Area 8. Does the website agree with the listing?
A: every service on the listing has its own page on your site; name, address, phone and hours match exactly; each provider with a practitioner listing has a bio page under the same name and credentials; and the site's hidden business details (schema) say the same things. C: the facts match but half the services have no page. F: the phone numbers differ, or there is no website.
Search engines and AI assistants read the listing and the site side by side and build their answers from both. The listing makes claims; the website is the evidence. Eight services against a one-page site is eight claims you can't cash.
Schema is the machine-readable version of the same agreement: your name, phone, address, hours and clinicians as labeled facts in the page's code, which site builders often fill with template values nobody checked. Paste your homepage into Google's free Rich Results Test to see what yours says. What schema is, in plain English. The standard each service page should meet is in what a practice service page should say.
The two areas that move first
Primary category
Describes the building rather than the clinician. Narrowing it to match what the winning competitors use takes under a minute.
Services field
Found completely blank or auto-filled. Adding your core offerings in everyday patient wording gives Google the exact queries to match.
When I have run this card on practice listings, the same two areas come back with the lowest letters: a services field that is completely empty, and a primary category that describes the building rather than the clinician. Both are free to fix, both take under an hour, and neither needs anyone hired. If you do two things from this guide, do those two.
Don't expect instant movement. Most edits show on the listing within minutes to a few days; some trigger a review by Google and take longer. Movement in the map results, if it comes, follows over weeks, and nobody can promise it. Re-grade after six weeks rather than checking daily. I checked daily for a month once and learned nothing except how to feel bad about a flat two weeks.
What to do with your card
Fix your lowest letter first. Re-grade in six weeks with the same eight areas and thresholds, so the comparison means something. The same measure every time is also what separates an honest monthly report from a flattering one; the questions to ask an SEO agency apply that test to anyone selling you search work.
If your card is mostly C's and D's and you would rather hand it over, the Google Business Profile setup is $250, one time, per location: all eight areas, every word shown to you before it goes live, and you stay the primary owner. It is included in the $950 Audit fix-up; the rest of the published prices are on one page.
If you want a second opinion on your letters, the free audit's profile report runs the same eight areas on your listing, from public information only, with the words to paste into each blank. Hold it next to your card.
Common questions about grading a Google Business Profile
- Google Business Profile Help: guidelines for representing your business on Google (names, practitioners, addresses, categories)
- Google Business Profile Help: how local ranking works
- Google Business Profile Help: choosing a business category
- Whitespark: local search ranking factors survey (practitioner survey, not a Google statement)
- Google Maps: policy on fake engagement and review solicitation
- FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, questions and answers
- HHS Office for Civil Rights: Manasa Health Center settlement, June 2023
- The A/C/F thresholds are Ark Visibility's rubric, drawn from listings we have graded. Google publishes no grade thresholds. A letter here is a measure for comparing your own listing over time, not a prediction of position.
- Every practice named on this page is invented.
This guide is general information, not legal or medical advice. Search and AI systems change; we review this page and date each review at the top.
Now you have a card
See how your listing grades out.
The free audit runs this rubric on your listing, field by field, from public information only, within two business days.
No card · No logins · No call · Yours to keep
By requesting an audit, you agree to our privacy policy. We do not sell contact information or make follow-up sales calls.